Trail of Blood
Following the Christians Down Through the Centuries . .
.
or
The History of Baptist Churches From the Time of
Christ,
Their Founder, to the Present Day
by J. M. Carroll
THIS LITTLE BOOK is sent forth for the purpose of
making known the little-known history of those FAITHFUL
WITNESSES of the Lord Jesus, who, as members of the CHURCH
JESUS BUILT, "Overcame Satan by the blood of the Lamb, and
by the word of their testimony: and they loved not their
lives unto death," Rev. 12:11.
I'd appreciate hearing from you--and may I ask
your help in getting these messages to our young people
and others. Tell them about the wonderful facts of history
brought out in this book. Urge them to order it. It would
be most helpful to study it as classes in the BTU, WMU,
and other organizations.
Introduction
By CLARENCE WALKER
I
Dr. J. M. Carroll, the author of this book, was
born in the state of Arkansas, January 8, 1858, and died
in Texas, January 10, 1931. His father, a Baptist
preacher, moved to Texas when Brother Carroll was six
years old. There he was converted, baptized, and ordained
to the Gospel ministry. Dr. Carroll not only became a
leader among Texas Baptist, but an outstanding figure of
Southern Baptists, and of the world.
Years ago he came to our church and brought the
messages found in this book. It was then I became greatly
interested in Brother Carroll's studies. I, too, had made
a special research in Church History, as to which is the
oldest Church and most like the churches of the New
Testament.
Dr. J. W. Porter attended the lectures. He was so
impressed he told Brother Carroll if he would write the
messages he would publish them in a book. Dr. Carroll
wrote the lectures and gave Dr. Porter the right to
publish them along with the chart which illustrates the
history so vividly.
However, Dr. Carroll died before the book came
off the press, but Dr. Porter placed them before the
public and the whole edition was soon sold. Now, by the
grace of God, we are able to present this 66th edition of
20,000. I want to ask all who read and study these pages
to join me in prayer and work that an ever-increasing
number shall go forth.
"To make all men see what is the fellowship of the
mystery which from the beginning of the world hath been
hid in God, who created all things by Christ Jesus; to the
intent that now unto the principalities and powers in
Heavenly places might be known by the Church, the manifold
wisdom of God ... unto Him be glory in the Church by
Christ Jesus throughout all ages, world without end,
Amen." (Eph. 3:9-10, 21)
II
It was wonderful to hear Dr. Carroll tell how he
became interested in the history of the different
denominations -- ESPECIALLY THEIR ORIGIN. He wrote the
book after he was 70 years old, but he said, "I was
converted unto God when I was just a boy. I saw the many
denominations and wondered which was the church the Lord
Jesus founded."
Even in his youth he felt that in the study of
the Scriptures and history, he could find the church which
was the oldest and most like the churches described in the
New Testament.
This research for the truth led him into many
places and enabled him to gather one of the greatest
libraries on church history. This library was given at his
death to the Southwestern Baptist Seminary, Ft. Worth,
Texas.
He found much church history -- most of it seemed
to be about the Catholics and Protestants. The history of
Baptists, he discovered, was written in blood. They were
the hated people of the Dark Ages. Their preachers and
people were put into prison and untold numbers were put to
death. The world has never seen anything to compare with
the suffering, the persecutions, heaped upon Baptists by
the Catholic Hierarchy during the Dark Ages. The Pope was
the world's dictator. This is why the Ana-Baptists, before
the Reformation, called the Pope The Anti-Christ.
Their history is written in the legal documents
and papers of those ages. It is through these records that
the "TRAIL OF BLOOD" winds its way as you find such
statements --
"At Zurich, after many disputations between
Zuinglius and the Ana-Baptists, the Senate made an Act,
that if any presume to re-baptize those who were baptized
before (i.e. as infants) they should be drowned. At Vienna
many Ana-Baptists were tied together in chains that one
drew the other after him into the river, wherein they were
all suffocated (drowned)." (Vida Supra, p. 61)
"In the year of our Lord 1539 two Ana-Baptists
were burned beyond Southwark, and a little before them 5
Dutch Ana-Baptists were burned in Smithfield," (Fuller,
Church History.)
"In 1160 a company of Paulicians (Baptists)
entered Oxford. Henry II ordered them to be branded on the
forehead with hot irons, publicly whipped them through the
streets of the city, to have their garments cut short at
the girdles, and be turned into the open country. The
villages were not to afford them any shelter or food and
they perished a lingering death from cold and hunger."
(Moore, Earlier and Later Nonconformity in Oxford, p. 12.)
The old Chronicler Stowe, A.D. 1533, relates:
"The 25th of May--in St. Paul's Church, London --
examined 19 men and 6 women. Fourteen of them were
condemned; a man and a woman were burned at Smithfield,
the other twelve of them were sent to towns there to be
burned."
Froude, the English historian, says of these
Ana-Baptist martyrs --
"The details are all gone, their names are gone.
Scarcely the facts seem worth mentioning. For them no
Europe was agitated, no court was ordered in mourning, no
papal hearts trembled with indignation. At their death the
world looked on complacent, indifferent or exulting. Yet
here, out of 25 poor men and women were found 14, who by
no terror of stake or torture could be tempted to say they
believed what they did not believe. History has for them
no word of praise, yet they, too, were not giving their
blood in vain. Their lives might have been as useless as
the lives of most of us. In their death they assisted to
pay the purchase of English freedom."
Likewise, in writings of their enemies as well as
friends, Dr. Carroll found, their history and that their
trail through the ages was indeed bloody:
Cardinal Hosius (Catholic, 1524), President of
the Council of Trent:
"Were it not that the baptists have been
grievously tormented and cut off with the knife during the
past twelve hundred years, they would swarm in greater
number than all the Reformers." (Hosius, Letters, Apud
Opera, pp. 112, 113.)
The "twelve hundred years" were the years
preceding the Reformation in which Rome persecuted
Baptists with the most cruel persecution thinkable.
Sir Isaac Newton:
"The Baptists are the only body of known
Christians that have never symbolized with Rome."
Mosheim (Lutheran):
"Before the rise of Luther and Calvin, there lay
secreted in almost all the countries of Europe persons who
adhered tenaciously to the principles of modern Dutch
Baptists."
Edinburg Cyclopedia (Presbyterian):
"It must have already occurred to our readers that
the Baptists are the same sect of Christians that were
formerly described as Ana-Baptists. Indeed this seems to
have been their leading principle from the time of
Tertullian to the present time."
Tertullian was born just fifty years after the
death of the Apostle John.
III
Baptists do not believe in Apostolic Succession.
The Apostolic office ceased with the death of the
Apostles. It is to His churches that He promised a
continual existence from the time He organized the first
one during His earthly ministry until He comes again. He
promised --
"I will build my church and the gates of hell
shall not prevail against it." (Matt. 16:18)
Then, when He gave the great Commission, which
tells what His churches are to do, He promised --
"I will be with you alway, even unto the end of the age."
(Matt. 28:20)
This Commission--this work--was not given to the
Apostles as individuals, but to them and the others
present in their church capacity. The Apostles and the
others who heard Him give this Commission were soon dead
-- BUT, His Church has lived on through the ages, making
disciples (getting folks saved), baptizing them, and
teaching the truth -- the doctrines -- He committed to the
Jerusalem Church. These faithful churches have been
blessed with His presence as they have traveled the --
TRAIL OF BLOOD.
This history shows how the Lord's promise to His
churches has been fulfilled. Dr. Carroll shows that
churches have been found in every age which have taught
the doctrines He committed unto them. Dr. Carroll calls
these doctrines the "marks" of New Testament Churches.
"MARKS OF THE NEW TESTAMENT CHURCH"
1. Its Head and Founder -- CHRIST. He is the
law-giver; the Church is only the executive. (Matt. 16:18;
Col. 1:18)
2. Its only rule of faith and practice -- THE
BIBLE. (II Tim. 3:15-17)
3. Its name -- "CHURCH," "CHURCHES." (Matt. 16:18;
Rev. 22:16)
4. Its polity -- CONGREGATIONAL -- all members
equal. (Matt. 20:24-28; Matt. 23:5-12)
5. Its members -- only saved people. (Eph. 2:21; I
Peter 2:5)
6. Its ordinances -- BELIEVERS' BAPTISM, FOLLOWED
BY THE LORD'S SUPPER. (Matt. 28:19-20)
7. Its officers -- PASTORS AND DEACONS. (I Tim.
3:1-16)
8. Its work --g etting folks saved, baptizing them
(with a baptism that meets all the requirements of God's
Word), teaching them ("to observe all things whatsoever I
have commanded you"). (Matt. 28:16-20)
9. Its financial plan -- "Even so (TITHES and
OFFERINGS) hath the Lord ordained that they which preach
the gospel should live of the gospel," (I Cor. 9:14)
10. Its weapons of warfare -- spiritual, not
carnal. (II Cor. 10:4; Eph. 6:10-20)
11. Its independence--separation of Church and
State. (Matt. 22:21)
IV
In any town there are many different churches --
all claiming to be the true church. Dr. Carroll did as you
can do now -- take the marks, or teachings, of the
different churches and find the ones which have these
marks, or doctrines. The ones which have these marks, or
doctrines, taught in God's Word, are the true
churches.
This, Dr. Carroll has done, to the churches of
all ages. He found many had departed from "these marks, or
doctrines." Other churches, however, he found had been
true to these marks" in every day and age since Jesus
said,
"I will build my church and the gates of hell
shall not prevail against it." (Matt. 16:18)
"I will be with you alway, even unto the end of the age."
(Matt. 28:21)
"THE TRAIL OF BLOOD"
or
Following the Christians Down Through the Centuries
From
The Days of Christ to the Present Time
Or to express it differently, but still
expressively -- "A history of the Doctrines as taught by
Christ, and His Apostles and those who have been loyal to
them."
FIRST LECTURE
"Remember the days of old. Consider the years of
many generations; Ask thy father and he will show thee.
Thy elders and they will tell thee." (Deut. 32:7)
1. What we know today as "Christianity" or the
Christian Religion, began with Christ, A.D. 25-30 in the
days and within the bounds of the Roman Empire. One of the
greatest empires the world has ever known in all its
history.
2. This Empire at that period embraced nearly all
of the then known inhabited world. Tiberius Caesar was its
Emperor.
3. In its religion, the Roman Empire, at that time,
was pagan. A religion of many gods. Some material and some
imaginary. There were many devout believers and
worshipers. It was a religion not simply of the people,
but of the empire. It was an established religion.
Established by law and supported by the government.
(Mosheim, Vol. 1, Chap. 1.)
4. The Jewish people, at that period, no longer a
separate nation, were scattered throughout the Roman
Empire. They yet had their temple in Jerusalem, and the
Jews yet went there to worship, and they were yet jealous
of their religion. But it, like the pagan, had long since
drifted into formalism and had lost its power. (Mosheim,
Vol. 1, Chap. 2.)
5. The religion of Christ being a religion not of
this world, its founder gave it no earthly head and no
temporal power. It sought no establishment, no state or
governmental support. It sought no dethronement of Caesar.
Said its author, "Render unto Caesar the things that are
Caesar's and to God the things that are God's." (Matt,
22:19-22; Mark 12:17; Luke 20:20). Being a spiritual
religion it was a rival of no earthly government. Its
adherents, however, were taught to respect all civil law
and government. (Rom. 13:1-7; Titus 3:1; 1 Pet.
2:13-16)
6. I want now to call your attention to some of
the landmarks, or ear-marks of this religion -- the
Christian Religion. If you and I are to trace it down
through 20 long centuries, and especially down through
1,200 years of midnight darkness, darkened by rivers and
seas of martyr blood, then we will need to know well these
marks. They will be many times terribly disfigured. But
there will always be some indelible mark. But let us
carefully and prayerfully beware. We will encounter many
shams and make-believes. If possible, the very elect will
be betrayed and deceived. We want, if possible, to trace
it down through credible history, but more especially
through the unerring, infallible, words and marks of
Divine truth.
Some Unerring, Infallible Marks
If in going down through the centuries we run upon
a group or groups of people bearing not these
distinguishing marks and teaching other things for
fundamental doctrines, let us beware.
1. Christ, the author of this religion, organized
His followers or disciples into a Church. And the
disciples were to organize other churches as this religion
spread and other disciples were "made." (Ray, Bapt,
Succession, Revised Edition, 1st Chap.)
2. This organization or church, according to the
Scriptures and according to the practice of the Apostles
and early churches, was given two kinds of officers and
only two -- pastors and deacons. The pastor was called
"Bishop." Both pastor and deacons to be selected by the
church and to be servants of the church.
3. The churches in their government and
discipline to be entirely separate and independent of each
other, Jerusalem to have no authority over Antioch -- nor
Antioch over Ephesus; nor Ephesus over Corinth, and so
forth. And their government to be congregational,
democratic. A government of the people, by the people, and
for the people.
4. To the church were given two ordinances and
only two, Baptism and the Lord's Supper. These to be
perpetual and memorial.
5. Only the "saved" were to be received as
members of the church (Acts 2:47). These saved ones to be
saved by grace alone without any works of the law (Eph,
2:5, 8, 9). These saved ones and they only, to be immersed
in the name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit (Matt.
28:19). And only those thus received and baptized, to
partake of the Lord's Supper, and the supper to be
celebrated only by the church, in church capacity.
6. The inspired scriptures, and they only, in
fact, the New Testament and that only, to be the rule and
guide of faith and life, not only for the church as an
organization, but for each individual member of that
organization.
7. Christ Jesus, the founder of this organization
and the savior of its members, to be their only priest and
king, their only Lord and Lawgiver, and the only head of
the churches. The churches to be executive only in
carrying out their Lord's will and completed laws, never
legislative, to amend or abrogate old laws or to make new
ones.
8. This religion of Christ to be individual,
personal, and purely voluntary or through persuasion. No
physical or governmental compulsion. A matter of distinct
individual and personal choice. "Choose you" is the
scriptural injunction. It could be neither accepted nor
rejected nor lived by proxy nor under compulsion.
9. Mark well! That neither Christ nor His
apostles, ever gave to His followers, what is know today
as a denominational name, such as "Catholic," "Lutheran,"
"Presbyterian," "Episcopal," and so forth -- unless the
name given by Christ to John was intended for such, "The
Baptist," "John the Baptist" (Matt. 11:11 and 10 or 12
other times.) Christ called the individual follower
"disciple." Two or more were called "disciples." The
organization of disciples, whether at Jerusalem or Antioch
or elsewhere, was called Church. If more than one of these
separate organizations were referred to, they were called
Churches. The word church in the singular was never used
when referring to more than one of these organizations.
Nor even when referring to them all.
10. I venture to give one more distinguishing
mark. We will call it -- Complete separation of Church and
State. No combination, no mixture of this spiritual
religion with a temporal power. "Religious Liberty," for
everybody.
And now, before proceeding with the history
itself, let me call your attention to--
I believe, if you will study carefully this, you
will better understand the history, and it will greatly
aid your memory in retaining what you hear and see.
Remember this chart is supposed to cover a period
of two thousand years of religious history.
Notice at both top and bottom of the chart some
figures, the same figures at both top and bottom - 100,
200, 300, and so on to 2,000.
They represent the twenty centuries of time --
the vertical lines separating the different
centuries.
Now notice on the chart, near the bottom; other
straight lines, this line running left to right, the long
way of the chart.
The lines are about the same distance apart as
the vertical lines. But you can't see them all the way.
They are covered by a very dark spot, representing in
history what is known as the "dark ages." It will be
explained later. Between the two lowest lines are the
names of countries . . . Italy, Wales, England, Spain,
France, and so forth, ending with America. These are names
of countries in which much history is made during the
period covered by the names themselves. Of course not all
the history, some history is made in some of the countries
in every period. But some special history is made in these
special countries, at these special periods.
Now notice again, near the bottom of the chart,
other lines a little higher. They, too, covered in part by
the "dark ages," they also are full of names, but not
names of countries. They are all "nick-names." Names given
to those people by their enemies. "Christians" -- that is
the first: "The disciples were called Christians first at
Antioch" (Acts 11:26). This occurred about A.D. 43. Either
the pagans or Jews gave them that name in derision. All
the other names in that column were given in the same
manner -- Montanists, Novationists, Donatists, Paulicians,
Albigenses, Waldenses, etc., and Ana-Baptists. All of
these will again and again be referred to as the lectures
progress.
But look again at the chart. See the red circles.
They are scattered nearly all over the chart. They
represent churches. Single individual churches in Asia, in
Africa, in Europe, in mountains and valleys, and so forth.
Their being blood red indicates martyr blood. Christ their
founder died on the Cross. All the Apostles save two, John
and Judas, suffered martyr deaths. Judas betrayed his Lord
and died in a suicide. The Apostle John, according to
history, was boiled in a great cauldron of oil.
You will note some circles that are solidly
black. They represent churches also. But erring churches.
Churches that had gone wrong in life or doctrine. There
were numbers of these even before the death of Peter, Paul
and John.
Having now about concluded with a general
introduction and some very necessary and even vital
preliminaries, I come to the regular history --
FIRST PERIOD A.D. 30-500
1. Under the strange but wonderful impulse and
leadership of John the Baptist, the eloquent man from the
wilderness, and under the loving touch and miracle -
working power of the Christ Himself, and the marvelous
preaching of the 12 Apostles and their immediate
successors, the Christian religion spread mightily during
the first 500 - year period. However, it left a terribly
bloody trail behind it. Judaism and Paganism bitterly
contested every forward movement. John the Baptist was the
first of the great leaders to give up his life. His head
was taken off. Soon after him went the Savior Himself, the
founder of this Christian religion. He died on the Cross,
the cruel death of the Cross.
2. Following their Savior in rapid succession
fell many other martyred heroes: Stephen was stoned,
Matthew was slain in Ethiopia, Mark dragged through the
streets until dead, Luke hanged, Peter and Simeon were
crucified, Andrew tied to a cross, James beheaded, Philip
crucified and stoned, Bartholomew flayed alive, Thomas
pierced with lances, James, the less, thrown from the
temple and beaten to death, Jude shot to death with
arrows, Matthias stoned to death and Paul beheaded.
3. More than one hundred years had gone by before
all this had happened. This hard persecution by Judaism
and Paganism continued for two more centuries. And yet
mightily spread the Christian religion. It went into all
the Roman Empire, Europe, Asia, Africa, England, Wales,
and about everywhere else, where there was any
civilization. The churches greatly multiplied and the
disciples increased continuously. But some of the churches
continued to go into error.
4. The first of these changes from New Testament
teachings embraced both policy and doctrine. In the first
two centuries the individual churches rapidly multiplied
and some of the earlier ones, such as Jerusalem, Antioch,
Ephesus, Corinth, etc., grew to be very large; Jerusalem,
for instance, had many thousand members (Acts 2:41; 4:4,
5:14), possibly 25,000 or even 50,000 or more. A close
student of the book of Acts and Epistles will see that
Paul had a mighty task even in his day in keeping some of
the churches straight. See Peter's and Paul's prophecies
concerning the future (II Pet. 2:12; Acts 20:29-31. See
also Rev., second and third chapters).
These great churches necessarily had many
preachers or elders (Acts 20:17). Some of the bishops or
pastors began to assume authority not given them in the
New Testament. They began to claim authority over other
and smaller churches. They, with their many elders, began
to lord it over God's heritage (III John 9). Here was the
beginning of an error which has grown and multiplied into
many other seriously hurtful errors. Here was the
beginning of different orders in the ministry running up
finally to what is practiced now by others as well as
Catholics. Here began what resulted in an entire change
from the original democratic policy and government of the
early churches. This irregularity began in a small way,
even before the close of the second century. This was
possibly the first serious departure from the New
Testament church order.
5. Another vital change which seems from history
to have had its beginning before the close of the second
century was on the great doctrine of Salvation itself. The
Jews as well as the Pagans, had for many generations, been
trained to lay great stress on Ceremonials. They had come
to look upon types as anti-types, shadows as real
substances, and ceremonials as real saving agencies. How
easy to come thus to look upon baptism. They reasoned
thus: The Bible has much to say concerning baptism. Much
stress is laid upon the ordinance and one's duty
concerning it. Surely it must have something to do with
one's salvation. So that it was in this period that the
idea of "Baptismal Regeneration" began to get a fixed hold
in some of the churches. (Shackelford, page 57; Camp p.
47; Benedict, p. 286; Mosheim, vol. 1, p. 134; Christian,
p. 28.)
6. The next serious error to begin creeping in,
and which seems from some historians (not all) to have
begun in this same century and which may be said to have
been an inevitable consequence of the "baptismal
regeneration" idea, was a change in the subjects of
baptism. Since baptism has been declared to be an agency
or means to salvation by some erring churches, then the
sooner baptism takes place the better. Hence arose "infant
baptism." Prior to this "believers" and "believers" only,
were regarded as proper subjects for baptism. "Sprinkling"
and "pouring" are not now referred to. These came in much
later. For several centuries, infants, like others, were
immersed. The Greek Catholics (a very large branch of the
Catholic church) up to this day, have never changed the
original form of baptism. They practice infant baptism but
have never done otherwise than immerse the children. (Note
-- Some of the church historians put the beginning of
infant baptism within this century, but I shall quote a
short paragraph from Robinson's Ecclesiastical
Researches.)
"During the first three centuries, congregations
all over the East subsisted in separate independent
bodies, unsupported by government and consequently without
any secular power over one another. All this time they
were baptized churches, and though all the fathers of the
first four ages, down to Jerome (A.D. 370), were of
Greece, Syria and Africa, and though they give great
numbers of histories of the baptism of adults, yet there
is not one of the baptism of a child till the year 370."
(Compendium of Baptist History, Shackelford, p. 43;
Vedder, p. 50; Christian, p, 31; Orchard, p. 50, etc.)
7. Let it be remembered that changes like these
here mentioned were not made in a day, nor even within a
year. They came about slowly and never within all the
churches. Some of the churches vigorously repudiated them.
So much so that in A.D. 251, the loyal churches declared
non - fellowship for those churches which accepted and
practiced these errors. And thus came about the first real
official separation among the churches.
8. Thus it will be noted that during the first
three centuries three important and vital changes from the
teachings of Christ and His Apostles had their beginnings.
And one significant event took place, Note this summary
and recapitulation:
(1) The change from the New Testament idea of
bishop and church government. This change grew rapidly,
more pronounced, and complete and hurtful.
(2) The change from the New Testament teachings
as to Regeneration to "baptismal regeneration."
(3) The change from "believers' baptism" to
"infant baptism." (This last, however, did not become
general nor even very frequent for more than another
century.)
9. "Baptismal regeneration" and "infant baptism."
These two errors have, according to the testimony of
well-established history, caused the shedding of more
Christian blood, as the centuries have gone by, than all
other errors combined, or than possibly have all wars, not
connected with persecution, if you will leave out the
recent "World War." Over 50,000,000 Christians died martyr
deaths, mainly because of their rejection of these two
errors during the period of the "dark ages" alone -- about
twelve or thirteen centuries.
10. Three significant facts, for a large majority
of the many churches, are clearly shown by history during
these first three centuries.
(1) The separateness and independence of the
Churches.
(2) The subordinate character of bishops or
pastors.
(3) The baptism of believers only.
I quote now from Mosheim -- the greatest of all
Lutheran church historians. Vol., 1, pages 71 and 72: "But
whoever supposes that the bishops of this golden age of
the church correspond with the bishops of the following
centuries must blend and confound characters that are very
different, for in this century and the next, a bishop had
charge of a single church, which might ordinarily be
contained in a private house; nor was he its Lord, but was
in reality its minister or servant. . . All the churches
in those primitive times were independent bodies, or none
of them subject to the jurisdiction of any other. For
though the churches which were founded by the Apostles
themselves frequently had the honor shown them to be
consulted in doubtful cases, yet they had no judicial
authority, no control, no power of giving laws. On the
contrary, it is as clear as the noonday that all Christian
churches had equal rights, and were in all respects on a
footing of equality."
11. Up to this period, not withstanding much and
serious persecutions, Christianity has had a marvelous
growth. It has covered and even gone beyond the great
Roman Empire. Almost, if not all the inhabited world has
heard the gospel. And, according to some of the church
historians, many of the original churches organized by the
Apostles are yet intact, and yet loyal to Apostolic
teachings. However, as already shown, a number of very
marked and hurtful errors have crept in and gotten a
permanent hold among many of the churches. Some have
become very irregular.
12. Persecutions have become increasingly bitter.
Near the beginning of the fourth century comes possibly
the first definite government edict of persecution. The
wonderful growth of Christianity has alarmed the pagan
leaders of the Roman Empire. Hence Galerius, the emperor,
sent out a direct edict of more savage persecution. This
occurred Feb. 24, 303 A.D. Up to this time Paganism seems
to have persecuted without any definite laws to that
effect.
13. But this edict failed so utterly in its
purpose of stopping the growth of Christianity, that this
same emperor, Galerius, just eight years thereafter (A.D.
311) passed another edict recalling the first and actually
granting toleration -- permission to live the religion of
Jesus Christ. This was probably its first favorable
law.
14. By the beginning of the year A.D. 313,
Christianity has won a mighty victory over paganism. A new
emperor has come to the throne of the Roman Empire. He
evidently recognized something of the mysterious power of
this religion that continued to grow in spite of
persecution. History says that this new emperor who was
none other than Constantine had a wonderful realistic
vision. He saw in the skies a fiery red cross and on that
cross written in fiery letters these words -- "By this
thou shalt conquer." He interpreted it to mean that he
should become a Christian. And that by giving up paganism
and that by attaching the spiritual power of the Christian
religion onto the temporal power of the Roman Empire the
world could be easily conquered. Thus the Christian
religion would in fact become a whole world religion, and
the Roman Empire a whole world empire.
15. So under the leadership of Emperor
Constantine there comes a truce, a courtship and a
proposal of marriage. The Roman Empire through its emperor
seeks a marriage with Christianity. Give us your spiritual
power and we will give you of our temporal power.
16. To effectually bring about and consummate
this unholy union, a council was called. In A. D. 313, a
call was made for a coming together of the Christian
churches or their representatives. Many but not all came.
The alliance was consummated. A Hierarchy was formed. In
the organization of the Hierarchy, Christ was dethroned as
head of the churches and Emperor Constantine enthroned
(only temporarily, however) as head of the church.
17. The Hierarchy was the definite beginning of a
development which finally resulted into what is now known
as the Catholic, or "universal" church. It might be said
that its indefinite beginnings were near the close of the
second and beginning of the third century, when the new
ideas concerning bishops and preacher - church government
began to take shape.
18. Let it be definitely remembered that when
Constantine made his call for the council, there were very
many of the Christians (Baptists) and of the churches,
which declined to respond. They wanted no marriage with
the state, and no centralized religious government, and no
higher ecclesiastical government of any kind, than the
individual church. These Christians (Baptists) nor the
churches ever at that time or later, entered the hierarchy
of the Catholic denomination.
19. When this hierarchy was created, Constantine,
who was made its head, was not himself at that time a
Christian. He had agreed to become one. But as the erring
or irregular churches which had gone with him into this
organization had come to adopt the error of Baptismal
regeneration, a serious question arose in the mind of
Constantine, "If I am saved from my sins by baptism, what
is to become of my sins which I may commit after I am
baptized?" He raised a question which has puzzled the
world in all succeeding generations. Can baptism wash away
yet uncommitted sins? Or, are the sins committed prior to
baptism washed away by one method (that is, baptism), and
the sins committed subsequent to baptism washed away by
another method?
20. Not being able to settle satisfactorily the
many questions thus arising, Constantine finally decided
to unite with the Christians, but to postpone his baptism
until just preceding his death, so that all his sins might
thus be washed away at one time. This course he followed,
and hence was not baptized until just preceding his
death.
21. Constantine's action in repudiating for the
whole Roman Empire, the pagan religion, and accepting
Christianity incurred the hot displeasures of the Roman
Senate. They repudiated, or, at least opposed his course.
And their opposition finally resulted in the removal of
the seat of empire from Rome to Byzantium, an old city
rebuilt and then renamed Constantinople for Constantine.
As a result there came to be two capital cities of the
Roman Empire -- Rome and Constantinople. The two rival
cities several centuries later became the ruling centers
of the divided Catholic church -- Roman and Greek.
22. Up to the organization of the Hierarchy and
the uniting of church and state, all the persecution of
Christianity has been done either by Judaism or Paganism.
Now comes a serious change. Christians (in name) begin to
persecute Christians. Constantine, desiring to have all
Christians join with him in his new idea of a state
religion, and many conscientiously opposing this serious
departure from New Testament teachings, he begins using
the power of government to compel. Thus begin the days and
years and even centuries of a hard and bitter persecution
against all those Christians who were loyal to the
original Christ and Apostolic teachings.
23. Remember that we are now noting the events
occurring between the years A.D. 300 and 500. The
Hierarchy organized under the leadership of Constantine,
rapidly developed into what is now known as the Catholic
church. This newly developing church joined to a temporal
government, no longer simply an executive to carry out the
completed laws of the New Testament, began to be
legislative, amending or annulling old laws or enacting
new ones utterly unknown to the New Testament.
24. One of the first of its legislative
enactments, and one of the most subversive in its results,
was the establishing by law of "infant baptism." By this
new law, "Infant Baptism" becomes compulsory. This was
done A.D. 416. Infants had been infrequently baptized for
probably a century preceding this. Insofar as this newly
enacted law became effective, two vital New Testament laws
were abrogated -- "Believers Baptism" and "Voluntary
personal obedience in Baptism."
25. As an inevitable consequence of this new
doctrine and law, these erring churches were soon filled
with unconverted members. In fact, it was not very many
years until probably a majority of the membership was
composed of unconverted material. So the great spiritual
affairs of God's great spiritual kingdom were in the hands
of an unregenerate temporal power. What may now be
expected?
26. Loyal Christians and churches, of course,
rejected this new law. "Believers baptism," of course,
"New Testament baptism," was the only law for them. They
not only refused to baptize their own children, but
believing in the baptism of believers only, they refused
to accept the baptizing done by and within the churches of
this unscriptural organization. If any of the members from
the churches of this new organization attempted to join
any of the churches which had refused to join in with the
new organization, a Christian experience and a rebaptism
was demanded.
27. The course followed by the loyal churches
soon, of course, incurred the hot displeasure of the state
religionists, many, if not most of whom, were not genuine
Christians. The name "Christian," however, was from now on
denied those loyal churches who refused to accept these
new errors. They were robbed of that, and called by many
other names, sometimes by one and sometimes by another,
"Montanist," Tertullianists," "Novationists," "Paterines,"
etc., and some at least because of their practice of
rebaptizing those who were baptized in infancy, were
referred to an "Ana - Baptists."
28. A.D. 426, just ten years after the legal
establishment of infant baptism, the awful period known as
the "Dark Ages" had its beginning. What a period! How
awfully black and bloody! From now on for more than a
decade of centuries, the trail of loyal Christianity is
largely washed away in its own blood. Note on the chart
some of the many different names borne by the persecuted.
Sometimes these names are given because of some specially
heroic leader and sometimes from other causes, and
frequently names for the same people vary in different
countries and even in different centuries.
29. It was early in the period of the "dark ages"
when real Popery had its definite beginnings. This was by
Leo II, A.D. 440 to 461. This, however, was not the first
time the title was ever used. This title, similar to the
Catholic church itself, was largely a development. The
name appears, as first applied to the Bishop of Rome
296-304. It was formally adopted by Siricius, Bishop of
Rome 384-398. Then officially adopted by Leo II, 440-461.
Then claimed to be universal, 707. Then some centuries
later declared by Gregory VII to be the exclusive right of
the papacy.
30. Now to sum up the most significant events of
this first five - century period:
-
The gradual change from a democracy to a
preacher-church government.
-
The change from salvation by grace to Baptismal
Salvation.
-
The change from "believers' baptism" to "infant
baptism."
-
The Hierarchy organized. Marriage of church and
state.
-
Seat of empire changed to Constantinople.
-
Infant baptism established by law and made
compulsory.
-
Christians begin to persecute Christians.
-
The "Dark Ages" begin 426.
-
The sword and torch rather than the gospel become
the power of God (?) unto salvation.
-
All semblance of "Religious liberty" dies and is
buried and remains buried for many centuries.
-
Loyal New Testament churches, by whatever name
called, are hunted and hounded to the utmost limit
of the new Catholic temporal power. Remnants
scattered over the world are finding uncertain
hiding places in forests and mountains, valleys,
dens and caves of the earth.
SECOND LECTURE-600-1300
1. We closed the first Lecture with the close
of the fifth century. And yet a number of things had
their beginnings back in those early centuries, which
were not even mentioned in the first Lecture. We had
just entered the awful period known in the world's
history as "The Dark Ages." Dark and bloody and awful
in the extreme they were. The persecutions by the
established Roman Catholic Church are hard, cruel and
perpetual. The war of intended extermination follows
persistently and relentlessly into many lands, the
fleeing Christians. A "Trail of Blood" is very nearly
all that is left anywhere. Especially throughout
England, Wales, Africa, Armenia, and Bulgaria. And
anywhere else Christians could be found who were trying
earnestly to remain strictly loyal to New Testament
teaching.
2. We now call attention to these Councils
called "Ecumenical," or Empire wide. It is well to
remember that all these Councils were professedly based
upon, or patterned after the Council held by the
Apostles and others at Jerusalem (see Acts 15:1), but
probably nothing bearing the same name could have been
more unlike. We here and now call attention to only
eight, and these were all called by different Emperors,
none of them by the Popes. And all these held among the
Eastern or Greek churches. Attended, however, somewhat
by representatives from the Western Branch or Roman
Churches.
3. The first of these Councils was held at
Nice or Nicea, in A.D. 325. It was called by
Constantine the Great, and was attended by 318
bishops.
The second met at Constantinople, A.D. 381,
and was called by Theodosius the Great. There were
present 150 bishops. (In the early centuries, bishops
simply meant pastors of the individual churches.)
The third was called by Theodosius II, and by
Valentian III. This had 250 bishops present. It met at
Ephesus, A.D. 431.
The fourth met at Calcedon, A.D. 451, and was
called by Emperor Marian; 500 or 600 bishops or
Metropolitans (Metropolitans were City pastors or First
Church pastors) were present. During this Council the
doctrine of what is now known as Mariolatry was
promulgated. This means the worship of Mary, the mother
of Christ. This new doctrine at first created quite a
stir, many seriously objecting. But it finally won out
as a permanent doctrine of the Catholic Church.
The fifth of these eight councils was held at
Constantinople (which was the second to be held there).
This was called by Justinian, A.D. 553, and was
attended by 165 bishops. This, seemingly, was called
mainly to condemn certain writings.
In the year A.D. 680 the Sixth Council was
called. This was also held at Constantinople and was
called by Constantine Pegonator, to condemn heresy.
During this meeting Pope Honorius by name was deposed
and excommunicated. However, at this time infallibility
had not yet been declared.
The Seventh Council was called to meet at
Nicea A.D. 787. This was the second held at this place.
The Empress Irene called this one. Here in this meeting
seems to have been the definite starting place, of both
"Image Worship" and "Saints Worship." You can thus see
that these people were getting more markedly paganized
than Christianized.
The last of what were called the "Eastern
Councils," those, called by the Emperors, was held in
Constantinople, in A.D. 869. This was called by
Basilius Maredo. The Catholic Church had gotten into
serious trouble. There had arisen a controversy of a
very serious nature between the heads of the two
branches of Catholicism -- the Eastern and Western,
Greek and Roman--Pontius the Greek at Constantinople
and Nicholas the 1st at Rome. So serious was their
trouble, that they had gone so far as to excommunicate
each other. So for a short time Catholicism was
entirely without a head. The council was called mainly
to settle, if possible, this difficulty. This break in
the ranks of Catholicism has never, even to this day,
been satisfactorily settled. Since that far away day,
all attempts at healing that breach have failed. The
Lateran-power since then has been in the ascendancy.
Not the Emperors, but the Roman Pontiffs calling all
Councils. The later Councils will be referred to later
in these lectures.
4. There is one new doctrine to which we have
failed to call attention. There are doubtless others
but one especially -- and that "Infant Communion."
Infants were not only baptized, but received into the
church, and being church members, they were supposed to
be entitled to the Lord's Supper. How to administer it
to them was a problem, but it was solved by soaking the
bread in the wine. Thus it was practiced for years. And
after awhile another new doctrine was added to this --
it was taught that this was another means of Salvation.
As still another new doctrine was later added to these,
we will again refer to this a little later in the
lectures.
5. During the 5th Century, at the fourth
Ecumenical Council, held at Chalcedon, 451, another
entirely new doctrine was added to the rapidly growing
list -- the doctrine called "Mariolatry," or the
worship of Mary, the Mother of Jesus. A new mediator
seems to have been felt to be needed. The distance from
God to man was too great for just one mediator, even
though that was Christ, God's Son, the real God-Man.
Mary was thought to be needed as another mediator, and
prayers were to be made to Mary. She was to make them
to Christ.
6. Two other new doctrines were added to the
Catholic faith in the 8th Century. These were
promulgated at the Second Council held at Nicea (Nice),
the Second Council held there (787). The first of these
was called "Image Worship, a direct violation of one of
the commands of God.
"Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven
image," (Ex. 20:3, 4, 5). Another addition from
Paganism. Then followed the "worship of Saints." This
doctrine has no encouragement in the Bible. Only one
instance of Saint worship is given in the Bible and
that is given to show its utter folly -- the dead rich
man praying to Abraham, (Luke 16:24-3l). These are
some, not all of the many revolutionary changes from
New Testament teachings, that came about during this
period of Church history.
7. During the period that we are now passing
through the persecuted were called by many and varied
names. Among them were Donatists, Paterines, Cathari,
Paulicians, and Ana Baptists; and a little later,
Petro-Brussians, Arnoldists, Henricians, Albigenses,
and Waldenses. Sometimes one group of these was the
most prominent and sometimes another. But some of them
were almost always prominent because of the persistency
and terribleness of their persecution.
8. Let it not be thought that all these
persecuted ones were always loyal in all respects to
New Testament teachings. In the main they were. And
some of them, considering their surroundings, were
marvelously so. Remember that many of them at that far
away, time, had only parts of the New Testament or the
Old Testament as to that. The book was not printed. It
was written in manuscript on parchment or skins or
something of that kind, and was necessarily large and
bulky. Few, if any, families or even simple churches
had complete copies of the whole Bible. Before the
formal close of the Canon (end of fourth century) there
were probably very few simple manuscripts of the entire
New Testament. Of the one thousand known manuscripts
only about 30 copies included all the books.
9. Furthermore, during all the period of the
"Dark Ages," and the period of the persecution,
strenuous efforts were made to destroy even what
Scripture manuscripts the persecuted did possess. Hence
in many instances these people had only small parts of
the Bible.
10. It is well to note also that in order to
prevent the spread of any view of any sort, contrary to
those of the Catholics very extreme plans and measures
were adopted. First, all writings of any sort, other
than those of the Catholics, were gathered and burned.
Especially was this true of books. For several
centuries these plans and measures were strictly and
persistently followed. That is, according to history,
the main reason why it is so difficult to secure
accurate history. About all persistent writers and
preachers also died martyr deaths. This was a
desperately bloody period. All of the groups of
persistent heretics (So-called) by whatever name
distinguished, and wherever they had lived, were
cruelly persecuted. The Donatists and Paulicians, were
prominent among the earlier groups. The Catholics,
strange as it may seem, accused all who refused to
depart from the faith with them, believe with them --
accused them of being heretics, and then condemned them
as being heretics. Those called Catholics became more
thoroughly paganized and Judaized than they were
Christianized, and were swayed far more by civil power,
than they were by religious power. They made far more
new laws, than they observed old ones.
11. The following are a few of the many new
variations that came about in New Testament teachings
during these centuries. They are probably not always
given in the order of their promulgation. In fact it
would sometimes be next to impossible to get the exact
date of the origin of some of these changes. They have
been somewhat like the whole Catholic system. They are
growths of development. In the earlier years
especially, their doctrines or teachings were subject
to constant change -- by addition or subtraction, or
substitution or abrogation. The Catholic Church was now
no longer, even if it had ever been, a real New
Testament Church. It no longer was a purely executive
body, to carry out the already made laws of God, but
had become actively legislative, making new ones,
changing or abrogating old ones at will.
12. One of their new doctrines or declarations
about this time was "There is no salvation outside of
the Church" -- the Catholic Church, of course, as they
declared there was no other -- be a Catholic or be
lost. There was no other alternative.
13. The doctrine of Indulgences and the Sale
of Indulgences was another absolutely new and serious
departure from New Testament teachings. But in order to
make that new teaching really effective, still another
new teaching was imperatively necessary: A very large
Credit Account must somehow be established -- a credit
account in heaven, but accessible to earth. So the
merit of "good works" as a means of Salvation must be
taught, and as a means of filling up, putting something
in the credit account, from which something could be
drawn. The first large sum to go into the account in
heaven was of course the work of the Lord Jesus. As He
did no evil, none of His good works were needed for
Himself, so all His good works could and would of
course, go into the credit account. And then in
addition to that, all the surplus good works (in
addition to what each might need for himself) by the
Apostles, and by all good people living thereafter,
would be added to that credit account, making it
enormously large. And then all this immense sum placed
to the credit of the church -- the only church(?)! and
permission given to the church to use as needed for
some poor sinning mortal, and charging for that credit
as much as might be thought wise, for each one needed
the heavenly credit. Hence came the Sale of
Indulgences. Persons could buy for themselves or their
friends, or even dead friends. The prices varied in
proportion to the offense committed -- or to be
committed. This was sometimes carried to a desperate
extreme, as admitted by Catholics themselves. Some
histories or Encyclopedias give a list of prices
charged on different sins for which Indulgences were
sold.
14. Yet another new doctrine was necessary,
yea imperative, to make thoroughly effective the last
two. That new doctrine is called Purgatory, a place of
intermediate state between heaven and hell, at which
all must stop to be cleansed from all sins less than
damning sins. Even the "Saints" must go through
purgatory and must remain there until cleansed by fire
-- unless they can get help through that credit
account, and that they can get only through the prayers
or the paying for Indulgences, by those living. Hence
the Sale of Indulgences. One departure from New
Testament teachings lead inevitably to others.
15. It may be well just here to take time to
show the differences between the Roman and Greek
Catholics:
-
In the Nationalities: The Greeks mainly are
Slavs, embracing Greece, Russia, Bulgaria,
Serbia, etc., speaking Greek. The Romans are
mainly Latins, embracing Italy, France, Spain,
South and Central America, Mexico etc.
-
The Greek Catholics reject sprinkling or pouring
for baptism. The Romans use sprinkling entirely,
claiming the right to change from the original
Bible plan of immersion.
-
The Greek Catholics continue the practice of
Infant Communion. The Romans have abandoned it
though once taught it as another means of
Salvation.
-
The Greeks in administering the Lord's Supper
give the wine as well as the bread to the laity.
The Romans give the bread only to the laity --
the priests drink the wine.
-
The Greeks have their priests to marry. The Roman
priests are forbidden to marry.
-
The Greeks reject the doctrine of Papal
"Infallibility," the Romans accept and insist
upon that doctrine. The above are at least the
main points on which they differ--otherwise the
Greek and Roman Catholic churches, it seems,
would stand together.
16. In our lectures we have just about gotten
through with the ninth century. We begin now with the
tenth. Please note the chart. Just here where the
separation has taken place between the Roman and Greek
Catholics. You will soon see as the centuries advance,
other new laws and doctrines -- and other desperately
bitter persecution. (Schaff, Herzogg, En., Vol. 11,
page 901.)
"THE TRAIL OF BLOOD"
17. I again call your attention to those upon
whom the hard hand of persecution fell. If fifty
million died of persecution during the 1,200 years of
what are called the "Dark Ages," as history seems
positively to teach -- then they died faster than an
average of four million every one hundred years. That
seems almost beyond the limit of, human conception. As
before mentioned, this iron hand, dripping with martyr
blood, fell upon Paulicians, Arnoldists, Henricians,
Petro Brussians, Albigenses, Waldenses and Ana-Baptists
-- of course much harder upon some than others. But
this horrid part of our story we will pass over
hurriedly.
18. There came now another rather long period of
Ecumenical Councils, of course not continuously or
consecutively. There were all through the years many
councils that were not Ecumenical, not "Empire Wide."
These Councils were largely legislative bodies for the
enactment or amendment of some civil or religious (?)
laws, all of which, both the legislation and the laws,
were directly contrary to the New Testament. Remember
these were the acts of an established church--a church
married to a Pagan government. And this church has become
far more nearly paganized than the government has become
Christianized.
19. When any people discard the New Testament as
embracing all necessary laws for a Christian life, whether
for the individual Christian or the whole church, that
people has launched upon a limitless ocean. Any erroneous
law, (and any law added to the Bible is erroneous) will
inevitably and soon demand another, and others will demand
yet others, without ever an end. That is why Christ gave
His churches and to preachers no legislative powers. And
again, and more particularly, that is why the New
Testament closes with these significant words,
"For I certify unto every man that heareth the
words of this book, if any man shall add unto these
things, God shall add unto him the plagues that are
written in this book. And if any man shall take away from
the words of the book of this prophecy, God shall take
away his part out of the book of life, and out of the Holy
City, and from the things which are written in the book."
Rev. 22:18, 19.
NOTE: We insert here this parenthetical clause, as
a warning. Let Baptist Churches beware of even
disciplinary and other varieties of resolutions, which
they sometimes pass in their conferences, which
resolutions might be construed as laws or rules of Church
government, The New Testament has all necessary laws and
rules.
20. The extreme limit of this little book
precludes the possibility of saying much concerning these
councils or law - making assemblies, but it is necessary
to say some things.
21. The first of these Lateran or Western
Councils, those called by the popes, was called by
Calixtus II, A.D. 1123. There were present about 300
bishops. At this meeting it was decreed that Roman priests
were never to marry. This was called the Celibacy of the
priests. We of course do not attempt to give all things
done at these meetings.
22. Years later, 1139 A.D., Pope Innocent II,
called another of these Councils especially to condemn two
groups of very devout Christians, known as Petro -
Brussians and Arnoldists.
23. Alexander III called yet another, A.D. 1179,
just forty years after the last. In that was condemned
what they called the "Errors and Impieties" of the
Waldenses and Albigenses.
24. Just 36 years after this last one, another
was called by Pope Innocent III. This was held A.D. 1215,
and seems to have been the most largely attended of
possibly any of these great councils. According to the
historical account of this meeting, "there were present
412 bishops, 800 Abbots and priors, Ambassadors from the
Byzantine court, and a great number of Princes and
Nobles." From the very make - up of this assembly you may
know that spiritual matters were at least not alone to be
considered.
At that time was promulgated the new doctrine of
"Transubstantiation," the intended turning of the bread
and wine of the Lord's Supper into the actual and real
body and blood of Christ, after a prayer by the priest.
This doctrine among others, had much to do with stirring
up the leaders of the Reformation a few centuries later.
This doctrine of course taught that all those who
participated in the supper actually ate of the body and
drank of the blood of Christ. Auricular confession --
confessing one's sins into the ear of a priest -- was
another new doctrine seemingly having its beginning at
this meeting. But probably the most cruel and bloody thing
ever brought upon any people in all the world's history
was what is known as the "Inquisition," and other similar
courts, designed for trying what was called "heresy." The
whole world is seemingly filled with books written in
condemnation of that extreme cruelty, and yet it was
originated and perpetuated by a people claiming to be led
and directed by the Lord. For real barbarity there seems
to be nothing, absolutely nothing in all history that will
surpass it. I would not even attempt to describe it. I
will simply refer my readers to some of the many books
written on the "Inquisition" and let them read and study
for themselves. And yet another thing was done at this
same meeting, as if enough had not been done. It was
expressly decreed to extirpate all "heresy." What a black
page -- yea -- many black pages were written into the
world's history by these terrible decrees.
25. In A.D. 1229, just 14 years after the last
awful meeting, still another meeting was held. (This seems
not to have been ecumenical.) It was called the council at
Toulouse. Probably one of the most vital matters in all
Catholic history was declared at this meeting. At this it
was decreed, the Bible, God's book, should be denied to
all laymen, all members of Catholic churches other than
priests or higher officials. How strange a law in the face
of the plain teaching of the Word, "Search the scriptures;
for in them ye think ye have eternal life: and they are
they which testify of me." (John 5:39)
26. Yet another Council was called to meet at
Lyons. This was called by Pope Innocent IV, in 1245 A.D.
This seems to have been mainly for the purpose of
excommunicating and deposing Emperor Frederick I of
Germany. The Church, the adulterous bride at the marriage
with the State in 313 in the days of CONSTANTINE THE
Great, has now become the head of the house, and is now
dictating politics of State government, and kings and
queens are made or unmade at her pleasure.
27. In 1274 A.D. another Council was called to
bring about the reuniting of the Roman and Greek branches
of the great Catholic Church. This great assembly utterly
failed to accomplish its purpose.
Click Here to
Continue
|